Free case evaluation 24/7

(866) 393-4334

What to Do If a Person Lies About Fault in a Car Accident

Legally reviewed by: Miriam Domer February 23, 2024
  • Law firms who have achieved over $100 million in case results

  • Many $20 million dollar jury verdicts

  • Law firms awarded Best Law Firm in 2022 by US News and World Report

If you’ve been involved in an auto accident and you believe the other driver lied about their fault in the collision, it’s important to avoid confronting them on your own. Car and truck accidents are complex situations and everyone involved often has their own interpretation.

If the at-fault driver did lie or has made a false statement, there are ample ways to evaluate their claim.

For example, the police will use various types of evidence, such as skid marks, to determine which vehicle caused the accident. This can help ensure only accurate information is included on the police report.

Working with a car accident attorney is the best way to ensure your side of the story is heard and that the rightful party is found at fault for the car crash.

If you need help finding an experienced car accident law firm to help you with your case, reach out to LegalFinders today.

Realizing that the other driver lied about their fault in a car accident

Realizing that the other driver lied about their part in a car accident can be frustrating. However, it’s important to remain calm and take the appropriate steps to ensure it’s handled properly.

The following are some tips to keep in mind in various situations should you find out the other driver’s statement or actions are false.

What to Do if the At Fault Party Lies Immediately After the Accident

Sometimes the at-fault party may tell false information about the crash right after the accident. If this is the case, here are some tips to consider when handling the situation:

Remain Calm

While dealing with an at-fault driver who isn’t being truthful about their role in a crash is certainly not easy, it’s important to remain calm. Losing your temper may result in saying things you ultimately regret down the road.

Remember that law enforcement will handle the situation and the untruthful motorist will likely be brought to justice.

Avoid Confronting the At-Fault Party

Another important tip to keep in mind after learning about the lie is to avoid personally confronting the at-fault party. This is true both at the scene of the accident and throughout the car accident claims process.

Speaking to the other party, whether via email, phone, or in person, can have a lasting negative impact on your insurance claim and its outcome.

Don’t Engage in Arguments

Similar to remaining calm, you should also avoid engaging in any arguments with the other party or the police. If you feel information is being left out or skewed, make a note of it and inform a police officer or your personal injury lawyer.

Don’t Admit Fault

Additionally, it’s important to avoid admitting any kind of fault in the accident. If you admit fault, this will likely be included in the accident report.

Having this changed can be difficult if not impossible and potentially result in you receiving little to no compensation through insurance, regardless of insurance coverage.

What to Do if You Find False Information on the Police Report

Some accident victims may notice there are discrepancies on a police report that don’t coincide with what actually happened at the scene of the crime. This information may include untrue witness statements, inaccurate claims of fault, or false reports of vehicle damage.

If you notice wrong information on a police report, consider doing the following:

Review the Police Report with Your Attorney

Rather than going to the police or other accident victims, first review the police report with your personal injury attorney, or car accident lawyer.

They can help you determine which information is truly falsified and whether you should take further steps to negate it.

It’s important to ensure the police report is accurate, as this is what insurance adjusters use when evaluating accident claims. Wrong information can negatively impact how the insurance company chooses to compensate a policyholder or accident victim.

Dispute the Police Report if Necessary

If your attorney feels it’s necessary to take further steps, you may consider disputing the police report. This can help ensure accurate information is listed on the report and that your injury claim has clear evidence supporting your case when submitted.

In most states, you can dispute a police report by reaching out to the police department and asking them to make an amendment. You may have to show evidence to support your request for the amendment.

What to Do if the At-Fault Party Lies During Your Car Accident Case

Another instance in which falsehoods may arise following an auto accident is during a car accident case. At-fault parties may lie in court to avoid higher insurance premiums, criminal charges, or even jail time.

They may also lie if they don’t have sufficient coverage through their insurance policy to avoid having to pay out of pocket for victims’ medical bills and other damages.

If you believe the at-fault party is lying, here are some options to consider.

Collect Strong Evidence

The best way to support your case in court is to arrive with as much sufficient evidence as possible to back your claim of what happened. You can do this by taking the time to gather evidence prior to your court date.

Examples of evidence to have for your case include:

  • Medical records
  • Medical expenses
  • Proof of damages
  • Phone numbers or other contact information of eye witnesses
  • Your own auto insurance policy information
  • Police reports
  • Any expenses and documentation associated with a wrongful death that occurred because of the accident

Your car accident attorney can help you gather this evidence as well as ensure you have what you need to win a fair settlement.

Share All Information with Your Car Accident Lawyer

You should also share all relevant information related to the car accident with your lawyer. This helps ensure they are aware of anything that may arise in court and can effectively defend your case.

Allow Your Lawyer to Handle Communications

It may be tempting to reach out to the at-fault party to talk to them about what’s been said. However, this can do more harm than good, especially when a case has gone to court.

It’s imperative that you allow your attorney to handle all communications between you and the other party throughout the extent of your case for your protection.

What Are Your Legal Options if the At-Fault Party Lies About Your Car Accident?

Your legal options will vary depending on how and when the at-fault party lied about the auto accident as well as the extent of the falsifications.

If you are allowed to file a claim, you will likely file a car accident claim (personal injury claim) to seek damages for any injuries or vehicle damage you incurred.

The best way to determine your legal options is to seek a free case review from an experienced auto accident attorney.

Hold Liable Parties Accountable with Help from A Trusted Car Accident Lawyer

If you’ve been involved in a car accident and you feel that the at-fault party is lying or not being held accountable through the insurance claim process or legal process, reach out to LegalFinders today.

We can help you find a dedicated car accident lawyer who can provide you with quality legal advice and guidance.

At LegalFinders, we have connections in every city throughout the country, making it easy to get in touch with a qualified and experienced legal team best suited to your unique case.

Article Sources

Allstate. “How is fault determined after a car accident?” Retrieved from:

Nerd Wallet. “What Is an At-Fault Accident?” Retrieved from:

Progressive. “What’s the difference between at-fault and no-fault accidents?” Retrieved from: